Security agencies raise alarm over commercial mapping

Published 26 June 2007

Security experts have long been uncomfortable with commercial mapping services such as Google Earth; more alrarms are raised

Yesterday we reported of the approval location-based services company Ituran received to buy Mapa Group, a big map publisher. This was but one story giving evidence of the growing popularity of location-based services and the growing activity in this segment of the market.

Not everyone is thrilled with this, however. The head of U.S. Air Force intelligence and surveillance, for example, said last week that data available commercially through online mapping software such as Google Earth posed a danger to security but could not be rolled back. “To talk about danger is, if I may, really is irrelevant because it’s there,” said Lt. Gen. David Deptula, deputy chief of staff for intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance. “No one’s going to undo commercial satellite imagery,” he told reporters in Washington, D.C.

Deptula cited Google’s Google Earth, which offers Web users an astronaut’s view of the earth and allows them to zoom down to street level. He said it had provided anyone with a credit card the ability to get a picture of any place on earth. “It is huge,” he said. “It’s something that was a closely guarded secret not that long ago and now everybody’s got access to it.”

Asked if the U.S. military might try to implement restrictions or blackouts on imagery of some areas, Deptula said he was not aware of such an attempt. “I don’t want to speak to specifics, but not that I’m aware of,” he said. Instead, governments are trying to mitigate the effect through camouflage, concealment and deception, he said, providing no other details.