IS Growing Stronger in Syria

The U.N. report said Islamic State still likely had between 3,000 to 5,000 fighters across Syria and Iraq, adding that the central Syria desert had become “a logistics and operations hub with 500 to 600 fighters.”

Still, many U.S. officials have expressed skepticism about the nature of the rebirth of IS in Syria.

The terror group is “struggling in many ways to mount a major capability that is relevant to the United States,” said National Counterterrorism Center Director Christine Abizaid during an appearance this week on the In the Room podcast with terrorism analyst Peter Bergen.

And the Worldwide Threat Assessment, issued last month by the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, cautioned that while IS remains a centralized global terror organization, “it has been forced to rely on regional branches in response to successive leadership losses during the past few years.”

Despite such differences, many counterterrorism officials and independent analysts agree Islamic State is still nowhere near reasserting itself in a way that resembles the terror group’s heyday six to eight years ago, when it controlled large swaths of Syria and Iraq.

Some caution, though, that even modest growth is reason for worry.

“The Islamic State always maintained capacity, even though it lost its control of Mosul and Raqqa and other strongholds,” said Bill Roggio, a senior fellow at the Washington-based Foundation for Defense of Democracies.

“It was never truly defeated … because we never do enough to actually defeat them,” Roggio told VOA. “And in places like Syria, it’s extremely difficult because who do you work with, who do you partner with to do that?”

The U.S. partner in northeastern Syria is the Kurdish-led SDF, charged not only with conducting ongoing operations to counter IS but it has also been responsible for a series of prisons holding some 9,000 former IS fighters and for overseeing security at displaced persons camps, like al-Hol, which remain home to tens of thousands of IS wives and children.

Further complicating matters, the SDF has increasingly found itself in conflict with Turkish forces, who view it as an extension of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party, or PKK, labeled as a terror organization by both Ankara and Washington. And some 900 mostly U.S. special forces in Syria have been distracted by recent drone and rocket attacks targeting U.S. bases by Iranian-backed militias.

Meanwhile, the U.S. and its SDF allies have little reach into parts of central Syria, where forces loyal to the Assad regime battle Islamic State cells with Russian support.

U.S. officials have long criticized those Syrian and Russian efforts as insufficient.

“The Russians really, in my estimation, are in the same mode as the U.S.,” Roggio said. “They’re doing enough to keep the Assad regime propped up and keep them alive and keep the pressure on the Islamic State. But they have bigger fish to fry in Ukraine.”

“They’re not devoting the resources and the energy to defeat the Islamic State in Syria,” he added.

And some former officials warn that any goodwill between Russia and the U.S. when it comes to battling the Islamic State has long since dried up.

“It’s [Russia’s] been consulted,” said Edmund Fitton-Brown, a former senior United Nations counterterrorism official who currently serves as a senior adviser for CEP. “And now we seem to have lost that.”

“That is a problem because some of the people who are best equipped to analyze and predict what might happen are not playing ball,” Fitton-Brown told VOA following last month’s IS attack in Russia.

The Kremlin is “capable of helping in this if they wanted to, but they don’t,” he said.

Experts and analysts warn these sorts of problems provide IS with fertile ground to grow its forces and its operations.

For now, though, those efforts still seem to be in the early stages.

“ISIS is not poised to capture major cities … and likely will be unable to capture smaller strategic objectives,” the CEP report said. “However, March’s attacks appear to show a pattern in which ISIS cells have seized control over much of the ‘empty’ space outside hardened regime positions.”

Jeff Seldin is VOA national security reporter.  This article is published courtesy of the Voice of America (VOA).