Demographics Alone Do Not Explain COVID-19 Mortality Rates -- Place Matters, Too

“Different groups are vulnerable in different ways,” said Qinyun Lin, a postdoctoral scholar at the center and the first author of the study. “In Hispanic groups, we found that many have high mortality rates in urban areas. We found those who are most vulnerable are in areas associated with a high percentage of working-age people and low insurance rates and severe housing problems.”

“Our research looks at COVID mortality rates, specifically the highest mortality rates in the first year of the pandemic,” said Paykin. “Then we look at how that matches with where different race and ethnicity groups live and we try to get at where high mortality rates disproportionately impacted different groups. And what social structural factors are associated with those outcomes?”

The researchers relied on two data inputs in particular. One was county-level COVID mortality data from the CDC, focused on the first year of the pandemic. They used county-level data from the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey and County Health Rankings & Roadmaps, which included demographics and community contextual factors. They looked at community-level variables such as income inequality, the ratio of population to primary care physicians, rates of preventable hospital stays, percentage of severe housing problems, percentage of internet access, and age distribution.

This data was then compared to previous literature on variables that have been shown to be associated with COVID-19 mortality. The team also spoke with their colleagues working on County Health Rankings for further insight.

The researchers are hoping their paper encourages information to be collected at a more granular level and shared freely—not only in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, but also to have in place for future pandemics or other natural disasters.

“We hope to show how place impacts COVID-19 outcomes,” Paykin said. “These outcomes are not driven by the people themselves, but rather the conditions that define the places in which they live. And that has really important implications for policy and structural changes and how we formulate and begin to prepare for the future and build a culture of health equity in general, for different populations across different communities in the U.S.”

As a next step, the researchers are looking to expand their datasets to include different ethnicities. The only reason they weren’t included in this study was because the level of available data was not large enough for statistically significant summaries. The current study is mainly exploratory and looks at associations. The researchers are also interested in digging deeper into different urban, rural and suburban settings to better understand the structural factors and drivers related to higher COVID mortality and death rates.

The team also hopes to take a closer look at the structural and social factors that describe very low COVID-19 mortality rates, to paint a better picture of what makes a community resilient—at least in the context of COVID impacts.