EnergyGrid adjustments cancel out some of wind power’s carbon savings

Wind energy lowers carbon emissions, but adding turbines to the current grid system does not eliminate emissions proportionally, according to a report by researchers at the U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) Argonne National Laboratory.

An Argonne Lab release reports that to test how wind energy affects carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions, Argonne scientists modeled the Illinois electric grid — power plants, production, and demand — and tested how more wind power would affect the system. They found that adjusting for wind power adds inefficiencies that cancel out some of the CO2 reduction.

It is actually the older technology in the background that hampers wind. Because the wind does not blow all the time, operators occasionally have to turn on extra fossil-burning plants to keep up with demand.

“Turning these large plants on and off is inefficient,” explained study author Lauren Valentino. “A certain percentage of the energy goes into just heating up the boilers again.” Power plants are also less efficient when they are not operating at full capacity.

Like many states, Illinois has pledged to get 25 percent of its energy from clean sources by 2025.

It still has a long way to go, however; in 2010, the state got 2.2 percent of its energy from wind.

“Illinois gets its strongest winds at night, when demand is low,” said co-author Audun Botterud, an Argonne energy systems engineer. “At the same time, we have a high fraction of very large, inflexible power plants in the system.” This is a problem because it’s inefficient to turn larger plants off and on to accommodate sudden influxes of wind power.

The best solution, he said, would be a way to store unused energy when the wind is blowing. We do not have a good way to store large amounts of electricity, a problem Argonne battery scientists are tackling elsewhere at the Argonne lab. In the meantime, smarter electric grids can help by leveling out demand.

The study, “Systems-Wide Emissions Implications of Increased Wind Power Penetration,” a collaboration between researchers at Argonne and summer interns Valentino (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign) and Viviana Valenzuela (Georgia Institute of Technology), was published in Environmental Science & Technology. Other Argonne co-authors are Zhi Zhou and Guenter Conzelmann.

In a related study published in Wind Energy, researchers investigated the use of advanced forecasting and operational strategies to accommodate more wind energy in the power grid.

The research was funded by the DOE’s Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy.

— Read more in Lauren Valentino et al., “System-Wide Emissions Implications of Increased Wind Power Penetration,” Environmental Science & Technology 46, no. 7 (5 March 2012): 4200–06 (DOI: 10.1021/es2038432); and Z. Zhou et al., “Application of probabilistic wind power forecasting in electricity markets,” Wind Energy (14 March 2012) (DOI: 10.1002/we.1496)